Thursday, November 19, 2026
Smart Again
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Politics
  • Law & Defense
  • Community
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Smart Again
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Politics
  • Law & Defense
  • Community
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Smart Again
No Result
View All Result
Home Community

At 30, “That Thing You Do!” is the perfect fake one-hit wonder

October 4, 2026
in Community
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0 0
A A
0
At 30, “That Thing You Do!” is the perfect fake one-hit wonder
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


With all apologies to David Lynch, in “That Thing You Do!” the film isn’t the thing.

Tom Hanks’ directorial debut, which was released to critical praise but was a box office disappointment, doesn’t hinge on the charming, passable performances of its lead actors. It doesn’t get by on its script, which tells the story of an out-of-nowhere rock ‘n roll band and their earworm of a hit song. Written by Hanks, the screenplay is so thin that the star lists out the stock types of each character in the third act. It definitely doesn’t get by on studio glitz; even if the production team did a bang-up job of recreating the early 1960s, they can’t get around the fact that much of this movie is set in a dreary Erie, Pennsylvania. Whether “That Thing You Do!” works for audiences — and the cozy, quick story of a flash-in-the-pan band has resonated with a ton of people since its release in 1996 — depends entirely on if the title song lands. 

Credit for that has to go to Adam Schlesinger, the late pop-rocker and bassist for Fountains of Wayne who wrote the track with nothing more than the film’s title and a few hints at the story. He needed to recreate the sound of the thousands of teenagers who had their heads rearranged by The Beatles and immediately ran to their garages to pick up guitars — and he nailed the teenybopper perfectionism of early Lennon-McCartney joints. The song’s backbeat is crisp. The bassline struts. The emotions are big, dumb and messy, but no one told that to the harmonies. Even the brief imitation of Lennon’s “losing control” scream is laser-precise, meant to boost the song’s momentum and carry it through a cheery and lazy surf solo. Give it a listen; it sounds like it was written by committee and by four bored teens in equal measure. It’s lightning. 

“That Thing You Do!” had to be that good, because no fictional rock band has ever leaned harder on their hit. The film follows the whirlwind, two-month career of The Wonders, a group so replacement-level that we first meet them arguing over “The” band names that are already taken. Drummer Guy Patterson (Tom Everett Scott) is the star of the film but the bassist joining him in the rhythm section, played in the film by Ethan Embry, doesn’t even have a name. (He’s listed as T.B. Player in the credits.) With lead singer Jimmy Mattingly III (Johnathon Schaech) and guitarist Lenny Haise (Steve Zahn) out in front, they go from local sensation to Billboard chart-toppers in weeks and implode just as spectacularly. Across that timespan, the audience is treated to “That Thing You Do!” in part or in full eight times, once every 13 minutes. Whether that’s the result of a threadbare script or just Hanks knowing what he had is up to the viewer to decide. What’s certain is that “Thing” never gets old.

Unlike The Wonders, Schlesinger’s ability to write a world-beating earworm was no fluke. He pulled off that trick multiple times. Just give a listen to “Pretend to Be Nice” from 2001’s “Josie and the Pussycats.” He’s the pen behind 2005’s “Just the Girl” by the Click Five, which laid a mall-emo whine and reverb-heavy drums over The Wonders’ tried and true formula. If you’ve heard of Schlesinger at all — and aren’t a power-pop geek or a “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend” superfan — it was likely through his band Fountains of Wayne and their 2003 hit “Stacy’s Mom.” Though that’s not his band’s best — that honor goes to “Radiation Vibe” or “All Kinds of Time” depending on the mood — it’s more proof that Schlesinger had a direct line to the idealized past in his brain. He could channel an undeniable pop hit out of that ether whenever he wanted.  

Talent like his is in short supply in 2026, especially after Schlesinger himself passed away in 2020. Watching “That Thing You Do!” climbing the charts throughout the movie is a peek into an alien musical world, one that was both more regional and more monocultural than the one we inhabit today. 

The song starts as a word-of-mouth sensation, filling a local restaurant as more and more teenagers hear about this new band and their soon-to-be hit from their friends. They press vinyl to sell at shows, and it gets into the hands of disc jockeys at ever-larger radio stations with an increasing number of watts behind their broadcasts. A labelman, played with equal parts tenderness and sleaze by Hanks, swoops in to take the boys on a tour of state fairs. When the song outgrows the blue-ribbon crowd, they’re flown to Los Angeles for one nationally televised performance before falling out in a bit of dressing room melodrama. 

Want sharp takes on politics? Sign up for our free newsletter, Standing Room Only, written by Amanda Marcotte, now also a weekly show on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.

The Wonders’ origins and skyrocketing fame built by the ability to press a record locally and impress radio programmers who curated their playlists by hand, are practically a fantasy in the consolidated media landscape of today. The idea of one song taking hold among the entire nation’s teenagers is even more ridiculous now that streaming has fractured the musical monoculture. Global connection came with a kind of dispersion, diluting shared connections closer to home while allowing for worldwide discovery.

For proof, just look at the (Wonder-less) Billboard charts today. Ella Langley’s “Choosin’ Texas” just broke the record for most weeks at No. 1 on the Hot 100. Meanwhile, the chorus of people who claim to have never heard the song grows louder every single day. The debate whether this is a mark of country music classism rages in the pages of the Rolling Stone, itself a bit of a relic from those more culturally unified days. 

“That Thing You Do!” hides its nugget of pop music consensus inside another bygone bit of shared culture: the afternoon cable movie. These easy lifts don’t ask you to think too much. They get in and out in under two hours, often starting as minor hits that become part of the cultural fabric through repetition; they’re on in the background and there when you need them. Films like “That Thing You Do!” are neither notable nor offensive to the typical viewer, and they never make you wonder “Who is this for?” If that question was ever asked, the answer is simple. It’s delivered in three-part harmony in the opening seconds of The Wonder’s lone pseudo-hit, gorgeous and unmissable. 

Who wants to listen to this Beatles pastiche, dreamed up to get Tom Hanks’ film studio off the ground? You.

Read more

from Alex Galbraith



Source link

Tags: fakeonehitPerfect
Previous Post

Trump Has A Total Meltdown Over Nobody Covering His Rallies

Next Post

“Oh my God! He tricked us!”: SNL’s Rubio and others panic over midterms

Related Posts

How a Black veteran’s brutal beating led to military desegregation
Community

How a Black veteran’s brutal beating led to military desegregation

November 7, 2026
Taika Waititi’s Instagram crash out is a Trumpian sore loss
Community

Taika Waititi’s Instagram crash out is a Trumpian sore loss

November 5, 2026
Tom Petty and The Who box sets reveal two sides of rock history
Community

Tom Petty and The Who box sets reveal two sides of rock history

November 3, 2026
Martha Stewart makes a grave Halloween costume mistake
Community

Martha Stewart makes a grave Halloween costume mistake

November 2, 2026
Trump hijacks SNL and David S. Pumpkins ahead of midterms
Community

Trump hijacks SNL and David S. Pumpkins ahead of midterms

November 1, 2026
Are Mount Everest climbers dreamers, or just cultists?
Community

Are Mount Everest climbers dreamers, or just cultists?

November 1, 2026
Next Post
“Oh my God! He tricked us!”: SNL’s Rubio and others panic over midterms

"Oh my God! He tricked us!": SNL’s Rubio and others panic over midterms

Trump’s appearance in Ohio underscores all the reasons the GOP is unpopular

Trump’s appearance in Ohio underscores all the reasons the GOP is unpopular

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
JB Pritzker Sets Trump And Kristi Noem Up For Halloween

JB Pritzker Sets Trump And Kristi Noem Up For Halloween

October 30, 2025
The end of free tax filing, briefly explained

The end of free tax filing, briefly explained

November 5, 2025
Ted Cruz Gets Heckled At Airport As He Tries To Blame Democrats For The Shutdown

Ted Cruz Gets Heckled At Airport As He Tries To Blame Democrats For The Shutdown

October 17, 2025
How soybeans took over the American diet – without anyone noticing

How soybeans took over the American diet – without anyone noticing

September 13, 2026
Live auctions are turning shopping into gambling

Live auctions are turning shopping into gambling

September 29, 2026
Five arrested near UK-US base in Iran terror probe

Five arrested near UK-US base in Iran terror probe

September 27, 2026
“They stole an election”: Former Florida senator found guilty in “ghost candidates” scandal

“They stole an election”: Former Florida senator found guilty in “ghost candidates” scandal

0
The prime of Dame Maggie Smith is a gift

The prime of Dame Maggie Smith is a gift

0
The Hawaii senator who faced down racism and ableism—and killed Nazis

The Hawaii senator who faced down racism and ableism—and killed Nazis

0
The murder rate fell at the fastest-ever pace last year—and it’s still falling

The murder rate fell at the fastest-ever pace last year—and it’s still falling

0
Trump used the site of the first assassination attempt to spew falsehoods

Trump used the site of the first assassination attempt to spew falsehoods

0
MAGA church plans to raffle a Trump AR-15 at Second Amendment rally

MAGA church plans to raffle a Trump AR-15 at Second Amendment rally

0
Ted Cruz Cries About Texas Turning Blue:  We Don’t Eat Tofu

Ted Cruz Cries About Texas Turning Blue: We Don’t Eat Tofu

November 19, 2026
EXCLUSIVE: ChatGPT helped “sadistic” school shooter build 3D-printed weapons

EXCLUSIVE: ChatGPT helped “sadistic” school shooter build 3D-printed weapons

November 19, 2026
Elon Musk thinks you’re dumb enough to believe he’s “not MAGA”

Elon Musk thinks you’re dumb enough to believe he’s “not MAGA”

November 19, 2026
How Nvidia’s chaos trickles down to you

How Nvidia’s chaos trickles down to you

November 19, 2026
Gen Z and Millennials Delay Marriage and Children Over Financial Insecurity

Gen Z and Millennials Delay Marriage and Children Over Financial Insecurity

November 19, 2026
JD Vance IS Getting What He Deserves As Trump Has Turned On Him

JD Vance IS Getting What He Deserves As Trump Has Turned On Him

November 19, 2026
Smart Again

Stay informed with Smart Again, the go-to news source for liberal perspectives and in-depth analysis on politics, social justice, and more. Join us in making news smart again.

CATEGORIES

  • Community
  • Law & Defense
  • Politics
  • Trending
  • Uncategorized
No Result
View All Result

LATEST UPDATES

  • Ted Cruz Cries About Texas Turning Blue: We Don’t Eat Tofu
  • EXCLUSIVE: ChatGPT helped “sadistic” school shooter build 3D-printed weapons
  • Elon Musk thinks you’re dumb enough to believe he’s “not MAGA”
  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2024 Smart Again.
Smart Again is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Politics
  • Law & Defense
  • Community
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2024 Smart Again.
Smart Again is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Go to mobile version