Braxton Wimbley was crying every day. Her fifth year of elementary school teaching at a public school in Indiana was, by far, her hardest. It was 2022, the first full academic year without Covid restrictions, and her fourth-graders’ social skills were “pretty much nonexistent,” she told Vox. “Because they had spent so much time at home doing whatever they want to do, [they] didn’t have structure and didn’t know when a teacher tells you no, that means no,” Wimbley, now 29, said.
Her students’ parents weren’t much help. Wimbley could see their exhaustion and empathized with the intensity of spending so much time with their kid during the pandemic. “I had parents blaming me for their child’s reading level, their child’s inability to do basic math, and I mean everything,” she said. One parent blamed her for the fact that her fourth-grader read at a kindergarten level. “I was like, ‘That’s not my fault.’”
Right before spring break, Wimbley wrestled with whether this career she had felt called to — growing up, she idolized Miss Honey from Matilda — was even right for her anymore. It was a painful thing to consider. And then a few days later, she was punched by a student. “After that, I was like, ‘Okay, I’m done. This is it,’” Wimbley said. Physically, she was unharmed. Her emotional state was another story.
A few years ago, one of my best friends left her job as a middle-school math teacher. For nearly a decade, she’d loved it — and, as her friend, I found her extremely suited to the job. After the pandemic, however, she decided to make a pivot into a new field altogether. Her reasons for leaving echo what many teachers told me: a lack of accountability among students and their parents.
Education is having a tough time hanging onto talent. According to one recent survey, one in four K-12 teachers said they’re very or somewhat likely to leave their job within the next year. Nearly 70 percent of teachers with less than five years of experience have considered leaving or already left the field because of poor working conditions, a lack of support, and low pay, another survey found.
The core functions of the job have changed dramatically, too. Smartphones, computers, and AI make it difficult to keep students’ attention. After years of remote or hybrid schooling during the pandemic, teachers said many students struggle with accountability and basic social skills. A focus on scores and teaching to the test have constrained educators’ ability to reach students.
But teachers aren’t the only ones facing an existential career crisis.
So many workers are feeling burned out and emotionally beat down. Americans uniquely derive a lot of meaning from their jobs — so much so that they are often defined by them.
“People who have the most meaningful jobs — personally meaningful — and it’s a calling, you do it with a sense of self-sacrifice and you’re willing to do it for fewer benefits, lower pay, and you spend more hours [there],” said Sarah Wittman, a professor of management at the Costello College of Business at George Mason University. “That’s often the case with teachers.”
The problems that educators face are a microcosm of the system problems that similarly plague any person working for a living in America today.
According to Gallup, 51 percent of US employees were either actively looking for a new job or keeping an eye out for new opportunities last year, a rate that increases to 61 percent of Gen Z workers. Food service and hospitality were among the top industries workers fled over the last few months. In a 2024 survey, 40 percent of nurses said they’d leave the workforce by 2029. Amid the Great Resignation of 2021, a Pew Research Center survey found that people left their jobs because of low pay, no room for growth, and feelings of disrespect.
That teaching, nursing and medical care, and hospital workers are at their wit’s end highlights the truth of burnout: it’s often the careers that give the most back to society that are susceptible to it.
And if we can’t collectively agree to support these professionals, who will our society go to bat for? In America, what careers are sustainable?
The fundamental role of teachers has changed
Since the 1890s, the typical school day in America has been fairly standardized. Teachers had their own classrooms, taught clearly defined courses — like science, geography, and math — assigned homework, graded tests, and sent home report cards. Instructors were the authority in their classrooms: they lectured, told students what to do and when, and set the standard for achievement.
More than a century later, educators had lost that control. Some report struggling with increased workloads and burnout, and, notably, after the pandemic, have seen increased student disruptions in the classroom, according to one study.
Nearly all teachers in one survey said students use technology in the classroom, effectively transforming the job from a tactile one to a digital one. Smartphones, computers, and AI make it difficult to keep students’ attention. Teachers must not only contend with distracted kids, but also take on the added responsibility of making their lessons engaging enough despite the screens. They wage constant battles with students who exclusively rely on AI for course work and who watch thousands of non-educational YouTube videos throughout the school day.
Sometimes instructors are told the screens are the lesson. During her final year of teaching, Wimbley had several students who didn’t understand English; they were fluent in French, Chinese, Spanish, and Haitian Creole — languages she did not speak. She did her best to communicate, using Google Translate to teach them; her goal for the year was for these students to at least know the American English alphabet, she said. When she reached out to the school’s English as a New Language (ENL) teacher for assistance, Wimbley was told to let the kids watch YouTube all day. “And to not worry about it,” she said. “I was like, ‘I can’t do that. That’s not happening.’” (In Indiana, where Wimbley worked, K-12 educators are required to teach language arts, mathematics, social studies, sciences, fine arts, and health and physical education, in addition to other topics.)
While Wimbley’s experience is egregious, insufficient funding has left classrooms across the US without crucial support, like teachers’ aides and ENL instructors. Public schools in America are supported by local, state, and federal governments. On a local level, property taxes help fund schools, which means wealthier areas receive more money. Districts with high poverty and greater populations of Black and Latinx students receive less funding than wealthier, majority-white areas.
Each state differs in their approach to school funding, but state legislatures determine how much money schools will receive from taxes and state contributions. More spending per child is associated with higher test scores and a greater likelihood of a student attending college. States like New York and Vermont spend over $25,000 per student, compared to less than half that in North Carolina and Idaho. Federal dollars account for only a small fraction of overall funding.
During the Great Recession in 2008, some states cut taxes and, subsequently, public school budgets; more than 350,000 K-12 teacher positions were eliminated. Even as an infusion of federal funds during the Covid-19 pandemic expired, many states cut taxes between 2021 and 2023, further depressing school budgets. Now, as enrollment plummets in districts nationwide, schools continue to struggle to keep up with costs, resulting in staff layoffs and school closures despite the fact that during the 2024-25 school year, over a third of public schools reported having one or more teacher job vacancies. Instead, advocates argue, states should increase revenue through higher taxes on the wealthiest people and corporations. But in few states is this the reality.
In this beleaguered system, teachers are asked to do more with less, expected to stock their own classrooms with supplies, and are lacking key resources (like aides, special education instructors, and mental health staff). All the while, their roles have become highly politicized: Elementary educators have been accused of teaching “critical race theory,” promoting “left-wing bias,” and “radically indoctrinating” students into activism.
Funding shortages aside, teachers said more intangible shifts have made their jobs untenable; namely, disruptive behavior that has increased since the Covid-19 pandemic. In the school where Wimbley worked, there were several classrooms where she estimated about half of the students had behavioral issues: they had difficulty focusing and controlling their bodies, and they would hit and curse at other students. Former Washington state and Texas public high school teacher Brenden Harthun, 28, told Vox his students had little interest in learning and would frequently interrupt class with disrespectful outbursts.
The issue, according to Harthun — which would eventually drive him from the classroom — is a lack of accountability from parents, school administrators, and the students themselves. If few people beyond a kid’s teacher stop to correct their behavior, the job becomes more about keeping kids in their seats than actual instruction.
True accountability in schools, according to Harthun, would involve hall monitors to ensure students stay in class, giving students accurate grades, being transparent with parents about their child’s progress, and offering plenty of opportunities for extra help and tutoring.
While the institutional failures underpinning teachers’ burnout can be traced to government funding, the causes of burnout in other industries are similarly tied to external factors that change the nature of their work. As companies roll out AI tools, workers find their workloads have not streamlined — AI just becomes another task to manage or a threat to their job altogether. Private equity is acquiring emergency rooms and pressuring doctors to be more productive, at the cost of patient care. Journalism has been hollowed out by billionaire owners and the changing whims of tech companies. Constant surveillance, and the risk of one bad TikTok review, has turned hospitality and running a small business into guest management.
The contexts in which many employees work have fundamentally changed — but the way we view ourselves through the lens of work hasn’t.
Americans have a particularly intimate relationship with their jobs. The Protestant work ethic, which emphasizes salvation through hard work and frugality, is one of our foundational ideals. When we ask “What do you do for a living?” we’re looking for a sign — of someone’s economic standing or power, of their integrity, of their status.
As fewer people are bound by their families of origin or geography or religion, they use their jobs to signal who they are and what they value. If, thanks to ongoing social and cultural change, you aren’t defined by roles like “spouse” or “parent” or “dependable neighbor,” a job title or something like “high performer” can be a good proxy.
Pursuing a career that is closely tied to your values can make the idea of leaving excruciating. Teachers are unique in that they can see the direct impact of their work day after day: the breakthrough moments, the new discoveries, burgeoning social skills. Losing teachers means a less consistent, stable, and reliable set of adults who can help young people foster their strengths and interests, especially over time. “For many kids, a teacher is one of the only stable and safe adults in their life,” licensed psychotherapist Annie Wright told Vox. “When that adult keeps changing…kids, especially kids who have really hard home lives, can learn that relationships don’t last, which is such a hard lesson to absorb at eight or 13.”
But a major, common downside of meaningful work is that the sacrifices erode sustainability. If the hours clocked at the office overtake the time spent with family, or a meager salary prevents you from actually living your life, you may come to the uncomfortable realization that this calling is no longer worthwhile.
When teachers or other professionals who derive purpose from their jobs consider leaving the field, it can feel threatening to their identities, their sense of self. “Because to the extent that it’s meaningful and you have to leave, your world comes crashing down,” Wittman, the management professor, said.
People might feel a discrepancy between their past as, say, a healer, and their current reality in another role. Teachers in particular can even feel guilty for abandoning their students. “I think that there’s a danger in what we’re doing with careers in having them be the center of our universe,” Wittman said.
Leaving a job can also impact the way others see you.
Mary Matthews, a 29-year-old who recently left elementary teaching, remembered telling an aunt she was considering quitting. Beleaguered by anxiety and a lawsuit a parent levied against Matthews and the school, she transitioned to part-time teaching last academic year. Matthews remembered telling her aunt, who is a special education teacher, of her decision: “She was like, ‘No, you can’t. It takes a special person like you. Too many teachers are leaving. You should stick it out. This is what you’re made to do,’” Matthews said. The comment’s not-so-subtle message, Matthews said, was that her departure was a moral failing.
“With teaching, they act like you’re letting a part of yourself go,” she said. “And it’s like, no, I’m still me. I’m still a good person. I just can’t do it anymore.”


























